Monta Monta Noble, Anthracite Dial vs Thomas Earnshaw Beige Black

The Monta Noble, Anthracite Dial takes the Sensei's nod on score (7.5 to 5.5), while the Beige Black is the value play at $149 ($1,746 less), and the Monta Noble, Anthracite Dial wears smaller at 38.5 mm. Tighter budget → the Beige Black; otherwise the Monta Noble, Anthracite Dial is the pick.